He looked like your neighbor. He worked as a computer programmer. He threw dinner parties for friends. But from 1971 to 1983, Randy Steven Kraft prowled the freeways of Southern California — and beyond — leaving a trail of young men’s bodies in his wake. When police finally caught him, they found something almost no one expected: a coded list. Sixty-one cryptic entries, each one believed to represent a life he had taken. Investigators called it the Scorecard.

More than fifty years later, victims are still being identified — and the case is still growing. This week on True Crime Tuesdays, we go deep into one of America’s most prolific and least-known serial killers: the man police called the Scorecard Killer, the Freeway Killer, and the Southern California Strangler. And we ask the question that haunts investigators to this day: how many names are still on that list?

On the evening of May 16, 2006, aspiring screenwriter Rey Rivera received a brief phone call, said “oh,” and ran out of his Baltimore home. He was 32 years old, newly married, and by every account a happy man on the verge of the life he’d always wanted. Eight days later, his body was found inside a locked, abandoned conference room at the historic Belvedere Hotel — beneath a hole in the ceiling that should have been impossible to make from above.

The physics didn’t add up. The injuries didn’t match. The detective assigned to the case said the scene looked staged and was pulled off it three weeks later. And taped to the back of Rey’s computer at home was a note — typed in tiny font, folded into a strange shape, addressed to “brothers and sisters” — that opened with a Masonic phrase, referenced volcanoes and secret societies and Stanley Kubrick, and was never satisfactorily explained by anyone.

This week on True Crime Tuesdays, we go to Baltimore, to a fourteen-story hotel, and to one of the genuinely strangest unsolved deaths of the past twenty years. No resolution. No clean answers. Just a hole in a roof, a note that reads like a riddle, and a case the medical examiner still considers open.